Home Up Contents Search

    Laughing Stock Farm, Freeport, Maine

 

Alkaline Catalysis

This simple process produces a reasonable quality biodiesel fairly reliably from unused vegetable oils with multiple esterification batches and several water washes to remove the impurities.  Unfortunately this process, by itself, will produce a poor quality biodiesel from the used fry oil available in Maine.

Unused or virgin soy oil, like other vegetable oils, consists of triglyceride molecules and typically has very low acid values. Picture a triglyceride as the capital letter E. The vertical line represents the glycerin backbone while the three horizontal lines represent the attached fatty acids that contain the biodiesel. The acid value is an indication of how complete the triglyceride molecules are in the mixture. As oil ages or is heated during cooking, the fatty acids break away from the glycerin backbone and become free fatty acids (FFAs). More FFAs increase the acid value of the mixture. This is important because the alkaline catalysis process, popular with small scale makers of biodiesel, and that will make biodiesel from triglycerides with low acid values, such as unused vegetable oil, will make very poor quality material from WVO or YG with high acid values.  These poor quality materials that do not meet the ASTM standard are NOT biodiesel.

In the alkaline catalysis esterification process, hazardous materials such as methanol (an alcohol) and an alkaline catalyst such as sodium hydroxide (lye) are used to separate the ester portion of the fatty acids on the glycerin backbone and replace the esters with alcohol to form glycerol. The ester, or biodiesel, floats to the top, while the glycerol and most of the other impurities settle to the bottom.  This separation looks much like water poured into a glass of cooking oil, where the water settles to the bottom and there is a distinct line that shows the separation.  

This same process is often erroneously recommended to make biodiesel from high acid value feedstock such as WVO or yellow grease. Alkaline catalysis will make soap from FFAs, especially if the feedstock contains moisture, as is most often true with waste vegetable oil. You may be familiar with this saponification process; it's the same one your grandmother used to make soap in the good old days. When the alkaline is used up in making soap, it is no longer available to break the esters free from the glycerin. Further, the soap will form stable emulsions of glycerin, salts, soaps, water and other impurities in the ester that will resist removal by the water wash. For this reason, the material that floats to the top and looks like biodiesel actually contains large concentrations of impurities that will damage diesel engines and produce harmful exhaust emissions. Several processes including hydrolysis and acid catalysis discussed here, can overcome this problem, but all involve more steps, more hazardous materials, and more cost.  

Biodiesel Quality Analysis

 

Send mail to lisa@laughingstockfarm.com with questions or comments about our farm
Send to ralph@rturner.com with questions or comments about our energy project. 
Copyright 2008, Laughing Stock Farm
Last modified: February 01, 2008